Financial Expert Proves Cash Is Better Than Shares

Financial Expert Proves Cash Is Better Than Shares
Las Paz Mexico by Julian Cohen. Why?

A fascinating piece of research by a respected financial journalist unearths the surprising fact that holding your money in cash would have produced a better return than investing in shares over many different time periods

Below Is A Lovely Little Video Showing The Incredible Amount Of Money Humans Have Created, But First, See How Cash Could Make You More Money Than Shares

Cash Or Shares? That Is The Question!

Paul Lewis, presenter of the Money Box programme on BBC Radio 4, compared the money you could have made from a low cost FTSE 100 Tracker fund invested in 1995 with the interest you could have earned on the best one-year fixed rate savings bond each year in the same period.

The conclusion is very interesting.  It challenges the conventional wisdom that over longer periods, the stockmarket will produce a better return than bank and building society deposits.

Cash Versus Shares Revealed

Paul’s analysis discovered interest earned on savings accounts beat the total returns generated from an HSBC FTSE 100 Tracker fund in more than half (57 per cent) of the 192 five-year periods beginning each month from 1 January 1995.

Over the longer term, the results were even more staggering. Over the 84 14-year periods from 1995, cash beat shares in an incredible 96 per cent of cases.

What’s relevant to pension holders, particularly if you’re drawing an income from your SIPP or SSAS, is that since 1995, the shares lost money in a third of the periods spanning one to 11 years. 

It’s not just the fact you might be down on your money in these periods.  The hidden and often dramatic knock-on effect of falling share prices is explained more fully in this article entitled Beware The Danger Of Pound Cost Ravaging.

Whilst it can’t be said of shares, your cash balance in savings accounts always ends up higher than it started.  But it’s also fair to say that in the research, cash accounts didn’t always come out on top.

Over the entire 21-year period between January 1995 and January 2016, the FTSE 100 Tracker fund produced an average return of 6 per cent per year.  It beat the return from cash accounts, which averaged 5 per cent per year.

Paul explained the 1 per cent difference is lower than the so-called 'risk premium payoff' investors are typically quoted of 3 per cent to 8 per cent when investing in shares.  He concluded:

Cash Beat Shares From 1995 To 2015


Paul Lewis

Twitter @paullewismoney

The data presented here allow the boundary between cash and shares to be set at around 18 years. Less than that, there is a better than evens risk that a shares tracker will produce a lower return than a series of best buy cash accounts. For periods below 12 years, there is also a risk that a shares investment will lose money. Overall, for a random date and a random investment period, the safer bet is active cash rather than tracker shares.

Cash is not right for everyone in all circumstances. But for a cautious person investing for periods of up to 20 years, this research indicates that well managed active cash beats a FTSE 100 Tracker more often than not.  And unlike a shares investment, it can never lose anyone money.

Cash Versus Shares Analysis

You can read Paul’s cash versus shares research.

If you want to check out the detailed ‘nuts and bolts’, which answers most questions including inflation, tax, time lags, crashes, other trackers and whether the last 21 years was typical, and is illustrated with tables and graphs, check out the cash versus shares analysis.

cash shares
cash shares

Discover How Much Money Have Humans Created, Including Cash And Shares, In This Marvellous Video

Please Share This

If you’ve found this page of interest, please would you kindly send a link to it to your friends and colleagues using the buttons below.  You’ll be helping us out, and they might like it too.  Thanks, it's much appreciated.


Closing 1 February 2019

Property protected investment paying up to 12 per cent per year.

Register NOW For Details

Get Valuable SIPP And SSAS Insights Emailed Directly To Your Inbox Every Monday

  • Please use an email address you can access. You can unsubscribe at any time.

As SIPPclub neither advises on, nor arranges, nor recommends specific investments or strategies, we're unable to say whether a SIPP or SSAS or any investment within it is right for you. Ultimately, it’s your money and your decision, and you should only proceed once you're satisfied you've undertaken sufficient due diligence. If you need advice, you should speak to your trusted adviser, or you could find a local adviser from  Alternatively, we'd be pleased to introduce to a suitably qualified independent financial adviser.

Please read our full Terms which includes criteria for SIPPclub membership.